Thyroid Screening in Pregnancy: Too Much of a Good Thing?

Often screening pregnant ladies for thyroid dysfunction could result in overdiagnosis, Canadian researchers reported.

In an evaluation of over 188,000 pregnant ladies, about 60% underwent no less than one measurement of thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH), in response to Jennifer Yamamoto, MD, of the College of Calgary, and colleagues.

Lower than 6% of those pregnancies had free thyroxine measured no less than as soon as, and solely 2.5% had thyroid peroxidase antibodies measured no less than as soon as throughout the being pregnant, they reported in CMAJ, the Canadian Medical Affiliation journal.

TSH measurement was most sometimes carried out in early being pregnant, between gestational weeks 5 and 6, whereas thyroid hormone remedy was normally initiated by about week 7.

Nevertheless, amongst ladies whose first TSH measurement mirrored subclinical hypothyroidism — a TSH between 4.01 to 9.99 mU/L — however who didn’t instantly begin hormone remedy, about 68% had a “regular” (under Four mU/L) studying on a repeat TSH measurement.

Among the many ladies who have been began on thyroid hormone remedy throughout being pregnant, almost half remained on this remedy after giving start.

Timing is especially essential right here as each the preliminary TSH measurement and initiation of thyroid hormone remedy “occurred in a interval when it’s properly established what TSH degree falls quickly due to regular physiologic modifications of being pregnant,” particularly between weeks 5 to 7 of gestation, the researchers identified.

“This raises considerations about overmedicalization throughout being pregnant, provided that minor, untreated TSH elevation normally normalized, as indicated by repeat measurement,” Yamamoto’s group acknowledged.

Higher restrict thresholds for diagnosing hypothyroidism in being pregnant have additionally seen some change over time.

Earlier pointers steered a TSH cutoff of suggestions for a TSH higher reference restrict of two.5 mU/L throughout the first trimester and three.Zero mU/L for each the second and third trimesters. Nevertheless, up to date pointers in 2017 from the American Thyroid Affiliation (ATA) recommend the higher reference restrict of 4.Zero mU/L ought to be utilized starting with the late first trimester (weeks 7 to 12), adopted by a “gradual return” in direction of the nonpregnant vary throughout the second and third trimesters.

For this retrospective cohort research, Yamamoto’s group drew upon information within the Alberta Perinatal Well being Program database. This included ladies between the ages of 15 and 49 who delivered a baby within the province. Ladies have been excluded if they’d proof of thyroid illness inside the prior 2 years earlier than supply, which was outlined as filling a prescription for any thyroid treatment, had a prognosis, or TSH measurement lower than 0.20 mU/L or 5.00 mU/L.

ALSO READ:   CrossFit CEO Greg Glassman Retires After Reaction from Racist Tweet

Throughout being pregnant, subclinical hypothyroidism was outlined in response to the 2017 ATA pointers, with a TSH vary between 4.01 to 9.99 mU/L. Overt hypothyroidism was outlined as a TSH of 10.00 mU/L or greater. Initiation of thyroid hormone remedy throughout being pregnant was outlined because the filling of a prescription for levothyroxine, desiccated thyroid, or liothyronine after conception however previous to supply.

Practically all pregnant ladies (99.6%) who initiated thyroid hormone remedy have been began on levothyroxine, at a median dose of 44.1 μg/day. The few different remaining pregnant ladies (0.4%) have been as an alternative began on desiccated thyroid remedy.

Among the many over 1,700 pregnancies the place the mom had an preliminary TSH measurement of 10.00 mU/L or greater (overt hypothyroidism), thyroid hormone remedy was solely began in about 18% of those circumstances.

“It’s not clear from these information why some ladies with TSH of 10 mU/L or greater didn’t obtain remedy with thyroid hormone,” the researchers acknowledged. “This may occasionally have occurred partly as a result of TSH fell under 4.01 mU/L in additional than 60% of these with repeat TSH measurement.” Additionally they posed the concept that these numbers could also be attributed to ladies not filling their prescriptions.

Then again, hormone remedy was initiated in about 8.5% of the pregnancies whose highest TSH measurement fell between 2.51 to 4.00 mU/L — under the higher restrict threshold. For the remaining ladies who had an preliminary TSH measurement within the subclinical hypothyroidism vary (4.01 to 9.99 mU/L), about 56% of girls have been began on hormone remedy.

“Medical follow pointers are wanted to present clinicians a stepwise strategy, based mostly on the very best present proof, for deciding whether or not and when TSH testing ought to happen,” Yamamoto’s group steered. “Steering can also be wanted as to when it’s acceptable to provoke remedy in being pregnant and proceed remedy within the postpartum interval.”

  • author['full_name']

    Kristen Monaco is a workers author, specializing in endocrinology, psychiatry, and dermatology information. Primarily based out of the New York Metropolis workplace, she’s labored on the firm for almost 5 years.


The research was funded by the Alberta Youngsters’s Hospital Seed Grant Fund.

ALSO READ:   Evander Holyfield Simply Shared a Glance of His Intense Return Training on Instagram

Yamamoto and co-authors disclosed no related relationships with trade.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here